@Jack_Toepfer Hmm, there's a lot to unpack from your comments and questions but I'll give it a shot. Firstly, I updated my graphs with extended notes which should help clarify some things, or maybe create more confusion.
If not excessive heat with the IHI, why go with the Whipple at all? I thought I read that the single largest limiting factor forcing people to go to bigger blowers was the very high temps when the blower is overspun. I don't think I'm seeing that in the data - at all. Is that possible?
Like you, I've read the same thing but I think it's a misconception or misinterpretation of what's happening and lack of knowledge of available options to mitigate the heat or unwillingness to enhance the intercooler setup. The act of compressing air is what generates the majority of all that heat so it makes sense that we get more heat with any PD blower the higher we go in boost. There isn't near enough focus on mitigating the heat as there should be. Why is that? Perhaps it's a secret or maybe there's just been too many failed attempts mixed in with successful ones of ice tank, chiller, or combination setups. Or maybe it's just too much effort? I dunno, but at this stage in the game, you have to be willing to face these issues and come up with strategies to mitigate against them.
@zhc - am I reading those graphs properly? Not sure I can extrapolate that if the ambient was the same for both blowers that the delta would get better or worse... Over time it looks like the IHI actually reaches some sort of equilibrium whereas the Whipple just keeps getting hotter.
There are too may changing variables to draw anything but the most simplest conclusions here. The one that I'm comfortable with is whatever heat these PD blowers generate can be mitigated with supplemental cooling from either ice tank, killer chiller, or some combination setup. I'm getting similar IAT's now with the Whipple as I did before when I had my over spun IHI and that's all thanks to how efficient my Killer Chiller setup is. I'm not sure if I'll see even lower IAT's when it gets colder but it does look like it based on my Dyno pulls. I'll find out in the next couple months.